soyjak.blog

SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
I wanted to correct your mistake, and there is nothing arguable about what I said above
TVTropesEnthusiast
prove there's a consensus
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
1738763345235.png

1738763370526.png


I have proven it so. The Iranians are shi'ites, they follow a deviant sect outside of the bounds of Islam according to most islamic scholars. Is that enough for you?
TVTropesEnthusiast
unfortunately not, you have given infographics that are not backed up by facts. presenting your argument in the form of an image does not make it any more convincing, and stating something as fact as you have done requires sources to back it up or it is just words on a screen.
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
The sources are in the picture. May Allah guide you
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
Imam Bukhari declared:

“I don’t see any difference between praying Salah behind a Jahmi or a (Shia) Rafidhi and a Christian or a Jew. They (Jahmis/Rafidhis) are not to be greeted, nor are they to be visited, nor are they to be married, nor is their testimony to be accepted, nor are their sacrifices to be eaten.”
(Khalq Af’aalul-’Ibaad, p.14)
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
Here's text for you. Imam Bukhari (may Allah be pleased with him) is one of the most credible scholars of Islam. The consensus of early muslims is that the shi'a are not muslims. You are arguing in bad faith to try and defend them as muslims, because this fact is known
TVTropesEnthusiast
unfortunately none of this really attacks the core point about MAPhammad marrying a 9 year old, i was simply using iran as another example of pedophilia in islam
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
And unfortunately you cannot prove that the shi'a are muslims, that is what I came to correct you on.
TVTropesEnthusiast
what are they then
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
Not Muslim, as I have proven above.
TVTropesEnthusiast
what makes a muslim? can you define that?
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
What do you mean by "define?"
TVTropesEnthusiast
tell me the meaning of the word muslim
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
One who submits (to Allah.) That is the meaning of the word.
TVTropesEnthusiast
do they not submit to allah?
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
What are you trying to argue for?
TVTropesEnthusiast
shia muslims, they submit to allah right?
SoytanEnthusiast
SoytanEnthusiast
They do not follow the sunnah of the Prophet, and Allah tells us to follow the Sunnah of the Prophet, so they are not Muslim.
TVTropesEnthusiast
different interpretations, no?
Back
Top